Until I Get to Page 400 Or So
I finished Until I Find You a few nights ago, before I began my Chuck Klosterman frenzy. To put this in perspective, I purchased Irving's last novel, The Fourth Hand, about two weeks after it came out in 2001, read it in three days, and have spent the four years in between waiting patiently for him to release his next one. Before that, I read A Widow for One Year in about three days within a week of its release in 1999 and had a two-year wait for the next one. It's true - I'd wait forever for this man to publish his summary of the phone book if that was my option for new Irving.
You see, I love John Irving more than I love any other author who has ever existed, and I suspect I always will. These are strong words, I'm aware, but I say them in all seriousness.
At the end of my sophomore year of high school, it fell to the underclassmen and -women to make sure all of the various left-behind junk in graduating seniors' dorm rooms was properly disposed of. I was put in charge of a room belonging to a girl named Mary Beth, a sarcastic, husky-voiced Southern girl who was pretty much the only person in the dorm whose relationship to me approximated friendship. She'd left the room a mess but told me I could take whatever I wanted out of it once she was gone. And under her bed was a paperback copy of The World According to Garp. I'd never heard of either the author or the book, but I knew that Mary Beth knew a lot about books (she was the head of the literary society I'd eventually be in charge of when I became a senior), and had generally good taste.
Ten years later, I've often thought about tracking Mary Beth down via our alumni network and thanking her for forgetting to take this book with her, because it was my gateway drug. Garp, I think, might be the best introduction to Irving you can get - it's alternately hilarious, strange, sad, and thought-provoking. It was as smart as anything I'd had to read for a class, but engaging in a way most 10th grade English Lit books aren't. (True, The Great Gatsby was an instant favorite, but Fitzgerald has always seemed a little bit detached to me. His work is the literary equivalent of the popular boy who's nice enough to the nerdy girl that she develops a crush on him, but not so nice that he'd actually date her.) Finishing the book took me exactly the length of my flight from Boston to Montana, and by the time I was done I not only wanted to write, I wanted to write a novel, and what's more, I wanted it to be this kind of novel.
That summer, I checked out The Cider House Rules from the public library and found The Hotel New Hampshire at a discount bookstore. My infatuation with Irving blossomed into true love.
That fall, I read A Prayer for Owen Meany, which hit me so hard that when I finished it, I just opened it back to the first page and read it again immediately. I estimate that in my lifetime, I have read that particular book at least 25 times, twice in German (because I figured I knew the book so well I could use it to improve my German reading comprehension). I wrote both my English Lit AP and my college entrance essay on it (not knowing when I sent my essays to Mount Holyoke that Irving had actually taught there at one point, so I imagine to the MHC admissions office I must have looked like I was really kissing ass. It must have worked, though, because that's where I wound up going). I can no longer choose one favorite book out of the hundreds in my apartment, but this one will always be in the top five, no matter how many other books I read.
Eventually I worked my way through all of them, even his first three, which are basically terrible. Aside from those, I've read all of them at least twice each. I planned a summer of backpacking in Europe around a visit to Vienna inspired by The Hotel New Hampshire. I have arranged to take the afternoon off from work so that I can go camp out in the Barnes and Noble where he'll be doing a reading/signing on August 18th. I actually saw Simon Birch more than once - in the theater. Such is the extent of my love for John Irving.
Obsessive? Maybe. But I'm a passionate person by nature, and really, this is a love reserved for only a very few things in my life, such as Elvis Costello and o-toro and the pajama pants I've had since I was 10. Besides, I want to draw you back to my earlier point, which is that Garp solidified my desire to be a novelist. Before that, I'd spent several months entertaining thoughts of going to a conservatory and becoming an orchestral tympanist (and maybe writing on the side). That's the last true vocation I considered before John Irving, and by extension writing, took over all of my other goals.
So back to the original impetus for this essay, which is Until I Find You. Overall, it's not bad. But it's not great, either.
The entire first half of the book chronicles the troubled childhood of Jack, the protagonist, whose tattoo-artist mother is doing her best to raise him single-handedly. Jack and his mother are plagued by the absence of Jack's church-organist father, a tattoo addict who allegedly disappeared before Jack was born. This would be sad enough for poor little jack, but also, every single female character in the book, apart from his mother, either molests him or wants to. Form the age of five up through high school, he's targeted by female pedophiles. After about 300 pages of this, I became a little desensitized to all the molestation (and the horrifying implication that half the time, Jack actually LIKES it), as well as the repeated mentions of Jack's penis. Keep in mind that Irving, as an author, managed to sell me on the incestuous relationship in The Hotel New Hampshire...but this...I just couldn't get behind it. And I couldn't make myself like any of the characters, least of all this poor kid who was at the center of it all. I couldn't like him precisely because everyone in the book seemed to, for varying reasons, and pretty much the only things they liked about him were his molestability. It almost made the prospect of feeling any sympathy for the kid seem creepy in and of itself.
Thankfully, once Jack graduates high school and moves out into the real world, the story picks up. It's hard to tell you exactly how this happens without giving away major plot points, but once Jack comes of age, things get interesting. Many of the characters we thought were good guys are bad guys, and vice versa. New motives are revealed that make you want to go back and experience the entire first two-thirds of the book again, knowing what you know now (ala The Sixth Sense or He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not or Rebecca). It's finally at that point that I started to like Jack, and identify with other characters. But it came too late for me to truly redeem the book. I just couldn't muster up enough affection for the characters even after the Big Twist turned all my perceptions on their ears.
As meh as I was about the book, I will concede that it's classic Irving. Nobody else could have written this. The book is rife with Irving in-jokes...at least I think they're in-jokes. Maybe "recurring theme" is a better description. At any rate, there are copious allusions to prep school, wrestling, freeing animals from zoos, seeming non-sequiturs as familial shorthand, oddly placed italics, and European prostitutes. And many others. Perhaps someday if I really have nothing better to do, like I break both my legs and this is the only book within arm's length, I might make a more comprehensive list.
Bottom line, I'm not sorry I bought the book, but it was ultimately a much less entertaining read than I had been waiting for these last four years. It's a little bit of a letdown. Of course it won't stop me from buying everything else the man ever writes for as long as he writes.
This is not to say that I don't still think the broken heart with "Until I Find You" emblazoned across it would make a really awesome tattoo. I'm just not sure it's for me. I hope someone out there loves the book enough to get it, though.
As for me, I still hope I'll get an Irving-themed tattoo at some point, but I can't think of what it would be. An armadillo maybe? I'm sure I can think of something better eventually. As it stands, I have two tattoos and plans for at least two more, so as much as I love Irving, a tattoo seems inevitable.
I pledge not to become one of the "full-body" types in Until I Find You, though.
I'll leave you tonight with my favorite paragraph from the book, spoken by a relatively minor character immediately after a fairly revelatory moment in Jack's quest to uncover his roots:
"I'll tell you what I believe about Hell...if you hurt people, if you know you're hurting them, you go to Hell. In Hell, you have to watch the people you hurt, the ones who are still alive. If two people you hurt ever get together, you have to watch everything they do very closely. But you can't hear them. Everyone in Hell is deaf. You just have to watch the people you hurt without knowing what they're talking about. Of course, Hell being Hell, you think they're talking about you - it's all you ever imagine, while you're just watching and watching."
If anything sticks with me from this book, it'll be that above all else. But it will be awhile before I know for sure how the book holds up as a whole.
(Note to John Irving and his lawyers: I realize that strictly speaking, this is probably a bigger chunk of quote than fair use would dictate I can have, but note all of the laudatory things I said about you above and take that into consideration before you slap me with a C&D letter. Thank you.)




